Still Waters, Silent Killer

• Documentary
• Crime

Episode overview

In Delaware County, Ohio, a man collecting garbage near Alum Creek Reservoir spots a large plastic tub bobbing in the water—with what looks like a human leg sticking out. The victim is soon identified as a local father who vanished just days earlier. As detectives trace his final hours—talking to roommates, scouring bar surveillance, and inspecting the tote—an ordinary barcode leads them to a chilling discovery: footage of the brutal murder itself. The case breaks open, but questions multiply.