Quarterfinal #4: Steven Weber, Shane Battier, Melissa Fumero

1. Quarterfinal #1: Mark Duplass, Emily Hampshire, Utkarsh Ambudkar2023-09-27 2. Quarterfinal #2: Brian Baumgartner, Lisa Ann Walter, Timothy Simons2023-10-04 3. Quarterfinal #3: Christopher Meloni, Sherri Shepherd, Katie Nolan2023-10-11 4. Quarterfinal #4: Steven Weber, Shane Battier, Melissa Fumero2023-10-18 5. Quarterfinal #5: Mira Sorvino, Adam Rodriguez, Peter Schrager2023-10-25 6. Quarterfinal #6: Dulé Hill, Sheryl Underwood, Peter Facinelli2023-11-01 7. Quarterfinal #7: Macaulay Culkin, Rachel Dratch, Becky Lynch2023-11-15 8. Quarterfinal #8: Cynthia Nixon, Cedric the Entertainer, Heather McMahan2023-11-29 9. Quarterfinal #9: Kyra Sedgwick, Mo Rocca, Amanda Seales2023-12-06 10. Semifinal #1: Utkarsh Ambudkar, Mira Sorvino, Lisa Ann Walter2024-01-02 11. Semifinal #2: Steven Weber, Katie Nolan, Dulé Hill2024-01-09 12. Semifinal #3: Rachel Dratch, Mo Rocca, Heather McMahan2024-01-16 13. Final: Mo Rocca, Lisa Ann Walter, Katie Nolan2024-01-23